• linkedin
  • Increase Font
  • Sharebar

    Is your scribe raising your risk of a malpractice lawsuit?

    Proper background checks, specialty training reduce likelihood of documentation errors

    Brianne Goodwin, JD, RNBrianne Goodwin, JD, RNConsider the following: You enter the exam room where your next patient sits gowned on the exam table. Your medical assistant has opened the patient’s electronic medical record (EMR). Next, you introduce your scribe, and indicate to the patient that the scribe will be documenting today’s visit so that you can pay closer attention to the patient and what he has to say.

    About 18 months later, the attorney representing your former patient is reviewing the record you, in conjunction with the scribe, have furnished after receiving the appropriate HIPAA release. Although you think you were well served with your EMR and your scribe, the attorney has a plan to show the record is fraught with error, which coincidentally is supporting the patient’s claim of injury.

    How could this have happened? You thought scribes were supposed to bolster the physician-patient relationship, improve patient satisfaction, and avoid your having to become facile with all the ins and outs of the EMR.

    Field minimally regulated

    Medical scribes are the fastest growing medical field, with the number of scribes doubling annually, and it is estimated that 100,000 will be employed by the year 2020 (bit.ly/Scribesincreasing). However, the field is minimally regulated and there are no requirements from an educational or background standpoint on who can be a scribe (bit.ly/ScribeFAQ). Scribes may be high school graduates or medical students, and are not required to be certified (bit.ly/Scribeinfo).

    Also by Brianne Goodwin, JD, RN - Informed consent: A medicolegal guide for urologists

    The Joint Commission (TJC) has offered the following guidance on the use of scribes: “A scribe is an unlicensed person hired to enter information into the EMR or chart at the direction of a physician or practitioner (Licensed Independent Practitioner, Advanced Practice Registered Nurse, or Physician Assistant).”

    The Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services agrees with this and the directive is that scribes may not act alone when documenting dictations or other activities determined by a physician (bit.ly/Scribesincreasing). TJC goes further and requires that all EMR entries are authenticated by a licensed practitioner (bit.ly/Scribeconcern). Given the prescriptive nature of this guidance from regulatory bodies, the role and function of a scribe may seem clear.

    However, a study conducted by a large medical malpractice insurer showed otherwise. This study showed high variability in the tasks that scribes were performing (bit.ly/Scribeuse). For example, 11.3% of physicians identified signing physician notes as an appropriate activity for a scribe, and 15.3% agreed that a scribe could participate in decision-making. Almost 45% of physicians felt that a scribe could respond to a patient message, and nearly 65% felt that scribes could provide translation services.

    This study, though based on a sample of just 335 respondents, shows that scribes are being used in capacities that extend much further than what TJC and CMS direct. At the end of the day, the physician is ultimately responsible for the medical record, not the scribe, so caution is urged in using scribes outside of the defined parameters (bit.ly/Scribeproscons).

    Further caution must be taken when an office clinical assistant is used as a scribe. For one, the scribe and the clinical assistant should have different permissions and security in an EMR, thus two different logins. Using the same person as a scribe and a clinical assistant for one encounter leads to multiple episodes of logging in and out and therefore risks error in documentation. For these reasons, having one individual fill the role of scribe and clinical assistant during one encounter is not recommended (bit.ly/Scribepractices).

    Next: Conduct proper background checks

    Brianne Goodwin, JD, RN
    Ms. Goodwin is manager of clinical risk and patient safety at Cambridge Health Alliance, Cambridge, MA.


    You must be signed in to leave a comment. Registering is fast and free!

    All comments must follow the ModernMedicine Network community rules and terms of use, and will be moderated. ModernMedicine reserves the right to use the comments we receive, in whole or in part,in any medium. See also the Terms of Use, Privacy Policy and Community FAQ.

    • No comments available