• linkedin
  • Increase Font
  • Sharebar

    Dear USPSTF: Don’t discount value of PSA in men 70+

    Editor’s note: The following letter was sent to the U.S. Preventive Services Task Force (USPSTF) in April 2017 after the USPSTF’s release of an updated draft recommendation on prostate cancer screening. The letter was subsequently sent to Urology Times following publication of an article discussing urologists’ reaction to the recommendation.


    Dear USPSTF,

    According to the draft USPSTF statement regarding prostate cancer screening:

    “For men 70 years and older, the draft recommends against PSA-based screening for prostate cancer (D recommendation). The evidence shows that prostate cancer is slow growing, and the 10-year survival rate is quite high. Rates of overdiagnosis are higher in older men, raising the concern that screening may result in more harm than benefit in this age group.”

    We have published three papers in peer-reviewed urology journals focusing on patients 70 years and older. These publications show that men 70 years and older have much higher rates of high-grade (Gleason score 7-10) prostate cancer, higher stages of prostate cancer, and higher prostate cancer-specific morbidity and mortality compared with patients 55-69 years old.

    Read - [Quiz]: Baby born with atypical genitalia, XY karyotype

    In 2013, we published, “A comparative analysis of prostate cancer pre-treatment characteristics stratified by age” (Can. J. Urol 2014; 21:7213–6). In our 402 U.S. patients, we found that, compared with patients <70 years old, in patients ≥70 years old:

    • 60.7% had high Gleason score (7-10) (p=.0234)
    • 39.3% had low Gleason score (6) (p=.0234)
    • 1% had PSA level ≥10 ng/ml (p=.0010)
    • 69.1% had high Gleason score (7-10) in the presence of a positive DRE (p=.0278).

    In 2016, we published the largest review ever of 5,100 U.S. prostate cancer patients age 70 and older, “Frequency of Gleason score 7 to 10 in 5,100 elderly prostate cancer patients” (Rev Urol 2016; 18:181-7) and found that:

    Based on analysis of 5,100 prostate cancer patients in our practice, we determined that 61% of prostate cancer patients age 70-80, 59% of those age 70-75 years, and 66% of those age 76-80 years have a high-grade prostate cancer. Since biopsy underestimates the grade in Gleason score 6 patients by about 50%, the actual frequency is approximately 80%. In patients with prostate cancer who had an abnormal DRE, 74% had a Gleason score 7-10, approximately 85% when accounting for biopsy undergrading.

    In 2017, we published a review of our patients titled, “Prostate biopsy characteristics: A comparison between pre- and post-USPSTF Prostate Cancer Screening Guidelines of 2012” (Rev Urol 2017; 19:25–31). In this study of 671 U.S. prostate cancer patients, we found that the prostate biopsy rate decreased by 30% post-USPSTF guidelines but the prostate cancer detection rate increased by 33.5%. High-grade Gleason score 7-10 prostate cancer increased by 5.4% post-USPSTF guidelines.

    Next: "Since the USPSTF recommendations of 2012, more advanced prostate cancer, metastatic prostate cancer, and prostate cancer-specific deaths have been documented."


    You must be signed in to leave a comment. Registering is fast and free!

    All comments must follow the ModernMedicine Network community rules and terms of use, and will be moderated. ModernMedicine reserves the right to use the comments we receive, in whole or in part,in any medium. See also the Terms of Use, Privacy Policy and Community FAQ.

    • No comments available